New York City's pied-à-terre tax is an annual surcharge on certain homes that are not used as a primary residence. For a buyer or owner, the important questions are the property's Department of Finance value, how it is used, and whether an exemption applies, not just its purchase price.
Updated November 12, 2026. This guide distinguishes the rules for tax years 2026–27 and 2027–28 from the later phase. It is general real estate information, not individual tax or legal advice; confirm your property's treatment with your attorney or tax adviser and the NYC Department of Finance.
The short answer for buyers and owners
- The surcharge is enacted, not simply an announcement of a possible future tax.
- For 2026–27 and 2027–28, co-ops and condos may be covered at a DOF market value of $1 million or more; one-, two- and three-family homes have a different threshold.
- Qualifying primary-residence use may exempt a property. An entry on the supplemental tax roll does not, by itself, mean tax is owed.
- DOF states that applicable charges will appear on the property tax bill due January 1, 2027.
Those points follow DOF's current surcharge guidance. The sections below explain the valuation distinction and the questions to resolve before committing to a home.
What Is the Pied-à-Terre Tax?
A pied-à-terre is generally defined as a secondary residence. It is a home that someone owns in a city but does not use as their primary residence.
The surcharge applies to certain high-value New York City residences that are not being used as a primary residence by an owner, qualifying family member, or bona fide tenant.
In simple terms, the policy is designed to target luxury homes functioning primarily as second homes rather than full-time residences.
Why do the tax thresholds differ?
One of the biggest sources of confusion surrounding the pied-à-terre tax is the apparent contradiction between the political messaging and the mechanics of the law.
The tax has largely been described as targeting luxury second homes valued at $5 million or more. Yet when discussing Phase 1, readers quickly encounter references to condominium and cooperative apartments with Department of Finance values beginning around $1 million.
So which is it?
The answer is both.
The $1 million threshold in Phase 1 refers to DOF market value, not the apartment's purchase price or a broker's estimate of resale value.
It is a Department of Finance valuation.
For many Manhattan condominiums and cooperatives, the Department of Finance value can be dramatically lower than the property's actual market value because the city often values these properties using income-producing methodologies rather than direct resale prices.
As a result, an apartment worth $10 million, $15 million, or even $18 million in the marketplace may carry a Department of Finance value that is only a fraction of its actual sale price.
This is why lawmakers created a two-phase system.
Phase 1 uses the valuation framework that already exists.
Phase 2 moves closer to a comparable-sales methodology that more closely reflects what buyers, sellers, lenders, appraisers, and brokers recognize as market value.
In other words:
Phase 1 speaks the language of the tax system.
Phase 2 speaks the language of the marketplace.
Once readers understand that distinction, the rest of the surcharge becomes much easier to follow.
NYC property classes
To understand why this happens, it helps to understand how New York classifies property.
Class 1 properties generally include one-, two-, and three-family homes.
Class 2 properties include most condominiums, cooperatives, rental apartment buildings, and residential properties with more than three units.
According to the NYC Department of Finance, Class 2 properties generally use a 45% assessment ratio when determining assessed value.
Class 3 properties generally include utility properties.
Class 4 properties generally include commercial and industrial properties such as office buildings, retail buildings, hotels, warehouses, and office towers.
For purposes of the pied-à-terre tax, the distinction between Class 1 and Class 2 is what matters most.
Why Condos and Co-Ops Are Valued Differently
Most people assume property taxes are based on what a property would sell for.
In New York City, that is often not the case.
For many Class 2 properties, including condos and co-ops, the NYC Department of Finance Class 2 Property Guide explains that properties are often valued using income-producing methodologies rather than direct resale values.
That can create a dramatic disconnect between a property's actual market value and its Department of Finance valuation.
For example, a condominium that sells for $18 million might carry a Department of Finance value of only $1.1 million.
That does not mean the apartment is worth $1.1 million.
It means the city is using a different methodology to determine taxable value.
This distinction becomes critically important when understanding how the pied-à-terre tax works.
What Is the 45% Rule?
Many owners hear the phrase "45% assessment ratio" and assume it is a tax rate.
It is not.
According to the NYC Department of Finance Assessment Methodology Guide , Class 2 properties generally use a 45% assessment ratio when converting market value into assessed value.
The simplified formula looks like this:
DOF Market Value × 45% = Assessed Value
So if a Class 2 property has a Department of Finance market value of $10 million:
$10,000,000 × 45% = $4,500,000 assessed value
That assessed value is then used as part of the city's broader property tax calculation.
The important takeaway is that assessed value, Department of Finance value, and actual market value are often three very different numbers.
Why Are There Two Phases?
The phased rollout exists because New York's current valuation system for condos and co-ops often produces values that bear little resemblance to actual market prices.
Rather than completely rebuilding the valuation system immediately, lawmakers created a transition period.
According to PKF O'Connor Davies, the two-phase structure appears designed to bridge the gap between New York City's current income-based valuation system and a future comparable-sales framework.
Phase 1 uses the valuation framework that already exists.
Phase 2 is intended to move toward a valuation method that more closely reflects actual market value through comparable sales.
Think of it this way:
Phase 1 speaks the language of the tax system.
Phase 2 speaks the language of the marketplace.
Surcharge rates for 2026–28
DOF publishes the following rates as a percentage of DOF market value, subject to applicability and exemptions. The brackets below reproduce its current rate table; confirm the treatment of your specific property with DOF and your adviser.
Property type | DOF market value | Annual surcharge rate |
|---|---|---|
One-, two- or three-family home | $5 million to less than $15 million | 0.8% |
One-, two- or three-family home | $15 million to less than $25 million | 1.05% |
One-, two- or three-family home | $25 million or more | 1.3% |
Condo or co-op unit | $1 million to less than $3 million | 4.0% |
Condo or co-op unit | $3 million to less than $5 million | 5.25% |
Condo or co-op unit | $5 million or more | 6.50% |
Source: NYC Department of Finance: non-primary residence surcharge. Do not apply these percentages to the asking price of a condo or co-op: the relevant value for this phase is the DOF market value.
For illustration only, a covered condo with a $1.1 million DOF market value and no applicable exemption would have a $44,000 annual surcharge at 4%. This is not an estimate for any particular listing, and ordinary property taxes and other carrying costs are separate.
Phase 2: The Market Value Reset
Beginning July 1, 2028, the tax enters Phase 2.
Rather than relying primarily on the existing Department of Finance methodology, Phase 2 is expected to move toward a comparable-sales framework that more closely resembles how buyers, sellers, brokers, lenders, and appraisers think about value.
Under Phase 2, the tax generally applies to covered non-primary residences valued at $5 million or more.
The later-phase rates described in the June 2026 PKF O'Connor Davies analysis are:
• $5 million to $15 million: 0.8%
• $15 million to $25 million: 1.05%
• Over $25 million: 1.3%
Do not treat a future-phase projection as today's tax bill. Before a purchase or a long-term ownership decision, have your adviser check the applicable tax year and current DOF guidance, as well as the property's valuation and exemption status.
Why This Matters Beyond the Ultra-Wealthy
Even if the pied-à-terre tax never affects you directly, it could still affect the market around you.
Luxury real estate values are ultimately driven by three things:
- Supply
- Demand
- Carrying Costs
Whenever ownership becomes more expensive, buyers adjust.
Some negotiate harder.
Some lower acquisition budgets.
Some rent instead of buy.
Some choose different neighborhoods.
Some redirect capital to competing markets.
Others simply absorb the additional cost and move forward.
The effect on buyer and owner behavior remains uncertain.
The question is how much.
That is why many industry observers believe the ultimate impact of the pied-à-terre tax may be less about the tax itself and more about the behavioral changes it creates throughout the luxury housing market.
Primary-residence exemptions
DOF lists qualifying primary-residence use by an owner, a tenant or subtenant, an immediate family member, certain majority-interest holders in an owning entity, or the sole beneficiary or beneficiaries of a trust. Eligibility and supporting documents depend on the facts; ownership through an entity does not by itself establish an exemption.
DOF's documentation checklist explains the evidence requested for occupants, tenants, family relationships and entity ownership. It also states that the 2026–27 exemption application deadline was October 13, 2026, and explains determination letters and appeal routes. If you received a notice or missed a deadline, contact DOF and your tax adviser promptly rather than assuming the property is automatically exempt.
How Might Owners Respond?
The biggest impact of the pied-à-terre tax may not be the tax itself.
It may be how people react to it.
The NYC Comptroller's analysis notes that behavioral responses such as renting units, changing residency status, or restructuring ownership could materially affect revenue projections.
- Examples already being discussed include:
- Renting out a second home rather than leaving it vacant
- Having a qualifying family member occupy the property
- Adjusting acquisition budgets
- Accelerating a planned sale
- Challenging Department of Finance valuations
- Reevaluating ownership structures
The common thread remains the same:
Who actually lives there?
Could This Increase Luxury Rental Inventory?
Possibly.
If a property leased to a bona fide primary-residence tenant qualifies for exemption treatment, some owners may decide it makes more financial sense to rent a property than leave it vacant.
For certain owners, the decision could become straightforward:
Pay the surcharge on an empty apartment, or generate rental income while potentially avoiding the tax.
If enough owners make that choice, the surcharge could add inventory to the luxury rental market over time.
Will People Stop Buying New York Real Estate?
Probably not.
New York remains one of the world's most desirable real estate markets.
However, the tax may influence behavior at the margins.
Luxury buyers evaluate total carrying costs just as carefully as purchase prices.
An additional annual expense of $50,000, $100,000, or even $200,000 can affect how buyers think about value.
Some may lower acquisition budgets.
Some may negotiate more aggressively.
Some may compare New York more closely with competing markets.
Others may decide that the benefits of owning in New York continue to outweigh the additional cost.
These are possible responses, not a prediction of demand.
For an individual buyer, comparing the full cost of ownership is more useful than assuming a particular market outcome.
Will Some Owners Sell?
Some may; the scale and timing are not established here.
The question is how many.
Owners who use an apartment only a few weeks each year may conclude that the added cost and administrative complexity are no longer worth it.
Others may continue to view their New York property as essential to their lifestyle, family, or business.
The result is likely to be segmentation.
Some owners will absorb the cost.
Some will rent.
Some will sell.
Some will restructure.
Some will challenge valuations.
And some will simply decide New York is still worth it.
Can This Law Be Changed?
Yes.
No law is truly permanent.
However, this is not something a future mayor can simply eliminate.
The pied-à-terre tax was enacted through New York State legislation as part of the state budget process. As reported by Reuters, meaningful amendments or repeal would generally require action from the New York State Legislature and the Governor.
A future mayor can advocate for changes and influence enforcement priorities, but major changes would likely need to occur in Albany.
The Bigger Question
Supporters see the pied-à-terre tax as a matter of fairness.
Critics see it as a tax on investment and capital.
But the larger debate may be about something else entirely.
This is ultimately a conversation about how New York defines residency, wealth, housing, and civic participation.
For some people, a Manhattan apartment is a home.
For others, it is an investment, a convenience, or a place to store wealth.
The pied-à-terre tax is designed to draw a distinction between those categories.
Whether it succeeds remains to be seen.
What is certain is that the surcharge represents one of the most significant changes to the economics of luxury homeownership in New York City in years.
And moving forward, one of the most important questions in Manhattan real estate may become:
Do you live here, or do you simply own here?
Comparing a Manhattan second home?
Send us the residences you are considering and how you plan to use them. We can help compare the real estate choices and organize the building and cost questions for your attorney or tax adviser. For related planning, read our Midtown pied-à-terre buying guide and NYC buyer closing-cost guide.
Sources and further reading
Current implementation: NYC Department of Finance surcharge guidance. Earlier sources below provide historical background and commentary, not a substitute for current implementation guidance.
Governor Kathy Hochul's Office
Pied-à-Terre Tax Proposal for Luxury Second Homes
https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-hochul-announces-pied-terre-tax-proposal-luxury-second-homes-valued-5-million-or-more
Reuters
New York State Budget Includes Tax on High-End Second Homes
https://www.reuters.com/legal/transactional/new-york-state-budget-includes-new-york-city-tax-high-end-second-homes-2026-05-28/
NYC Department of Finance
Class 2 Property Guide
https://www.nyc.gov/assets/finance/downloads/pdf/brochures/class_2_guide.pdf
NYC Department of Finance
Determining Assessed Value
https://www.nyc.gov/site/finance/property/property-determining-your-assessed-value.page
NYC Comptroller
The Pied-à-Terre Tax and Its Potential Revenues
https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/the-pied-a-terre-tax-and-its-potential-revenues/
PKF O'Connor Davies
What Co-op, Condo and Investment Property Owners Should Know About NYC's Newly Passed Pied-à-Terre Tax
https://www.pkfod.com/insights/what-co-op-condo-and-investment-property-owners-should-know-about-nycs-newly-passed-pied-a-terre-tax/
Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY)
Pied-à-Terre Tax Presentation Materials (2026)