The rarest amenity in the city, and the one we know best.
A 6,845-square-foot duplex penthouse with 2,300 square feet of private terraces and a private swimming pool. Sold for $17,700,000 in January 2021. The Roya Cohen Team represented the seller and the buyer.
The pool in the photo above. A 5,847-square-foot duplex with 20-foot ceilings and a 3,852-square-foot terrace over the Hudson, with a private 37-foot pool on it. Sold for $13,150,000 in April 2021, the highest sale recorded in the building. The Roya Cohen Team represented the seller. Read about The Aldyn.
Bought before construction was finished, from a floor plan and a hard-hat visit. The pool was not in the building's plans. It was negotiated, engineered and built for the client after the contract was signed. The Roya Cohen Team represented the buyer.
A client's story
Nothing on the market had all four. So Roya showed him a penthouse that was still under construction, walked the unfinished space with him so he could judge the height and the dimensions for himself, and then took on the harder part: getting the developer to agree to a pool the building had never planned for, and seeing it engineered and built.
In his words: "We had established a good working relationship with a level of trust. And that's why I moved forward."
Press play to hear the whole story from him.
How it works
Water weighs about 62 pounds per cubic foot. A 37-foot pool holds tens of tons of it, and most Manhattan buildings were never engineered to carry that on a terrace or a roof. Add the plumbing, the heating, the drainage into the city sewer, the Department of Buildings permits and the board's alteration agreement, and you understand why a handful of residences have one and almost nobody builds one. A terrace is a luxury. A pool on it is a category of one.
There is no private pool filter on StreetEasy, and listings often bury the pool in the tenth sentence or leave it to the photos. So we keep our own running list of the buildings and specific residences where a pool exists or could be engineered: townhouses with garden or roof capacity, penthouses with large terraces over structural columns, new developments still flexible enough to change a plan. The search starts from that list and from direct conversations with owners and sponsors, not from a portal.
While we do not build pools, we are the ones who find the residences that can hold one, bring the right engineers and builders to the table, and manage the process so the client is not the one chasing permits.
Very few, and there is no public count because listing sites do not track it as a feature. In practice it is a short list of penthouses, townhouses and a few newer condominiums whose structure was designed for the load. Scarcity is why these homes trade on relationships and direct outreach more than on portal searches.
Sometimes. It depends first on structure, then on the building's rules, then on permits. A large terrace over structural columns, a townhouse roof or garden, or a new development still under construction are the realistic candidates. We have been through this once already with a client and know the order the questions get asked in.
The building's board or sponsor through an alteration agreement, the New York City Department of Buildings through permits filed by a licensed engineer or architect, and the Department of Environmental Protection for drainage. Electrical and plumbing work carry their own permits.
It makes a home one of a kind, which widens the gap between it and anything else on the market. We do not promise a specific premium. What we can say from our own sales is that the two pool residences we sold set the record in their buildings at the time.
No. We sell across Manhattan, with a long record on the Upper West Side and Riverside Boulevard. Private pools are a specialty because we have done it three times and know what it takes, and we bring that same attention to any home with significant outdoor space.
Ready to take the plunge? Tell us what your dream pool looks like: laps in the morning, a plunge pool, a hot tub, or somewhere to cool off with friends in August. That tells us the size, depth and heating you need, and which buildings can carry it. From there we check our list and start making calls. The listings above are what is public today. Most of the pools we have sold never were.